is the film I am talking about. Now as you may know, i did read the book earlier and I loved it. I mean 5 out of 5 is a pretty good recommendation. I love Carey Mulligan and I have been looking forward to seeing this film since I read a small one paragraph about it in an old old old edition of Vanity Fair over a year ago. But I am a practical person, I didn't get too excited about it because when you look forward to a film a little too much you will be let down, a lot. So I was practical going in to the film and I was only let down a little bit.
The excitement of the book is in the not knowing; you want to keep reading so you can find out just what is going on. It's never really, properly said; there are weird little phrases that the characters use, and as the novel progresses we start to realise what these words really mean. But in the film the mystery is dissolved right at the start of the film and what is left is a pale, shallow adaptation of an exciting and thought provoking story.
If you've seen some of the recent trailers and reviews, you know the story already and I won't be spoiling any surprises. The three main characters Tommy, Kathy and Ruth are clones, raised in an idyllic English boarding school under the tight watch of their guardians. They indulge in sport and art and until new guardian Miss Lucy arrives, the ignorance of youth. But Miss Lucy spoils the surprise and tells them that they will grow into adults and not reach middle age because they will start being called in to make "donations", meaning their vital organs will be harvested until they "complete". Part of the romance of the novel is not knowing, just like the mystery and romance of Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep is not knowing whether or not Deckard is a Replicant. Ridley Scott gets this and that's why the film adaptation Blade Runner is such a respected, classic film.
The performances were amazing, nobody, not even me, can take that away from Carey Mulligan, Andrew Garfield and Keira Knightley. The film is lovingly shot and beautifully photographic, which is no great surprise considering what other films cinematographer Adam Kimmel has worked on. But none of this can save the lack of character development in the film. The relationships make no sense what so ever and the sheer speed with which we are whipped through the story is staggering and I fear, like the fourth Harry Potter film, those who have not read the book would not understand either the story line or the complexities of the characters.
I had a real problem with this film though I am sure people will enjoy it. I personally wouldn't bother, but it is a pretty film filled with good performances.